Low Carb Snacks: Peanut Butter Cookies | Chocolate Cheesecake | Protein Ice Cream | Chocolate-Coconut Muffins | Guilt-Free Custard

Emotional Eating: Instinct vs Reasoning

12

by Olesya Novik

As mentioned in last week’s article, there are many different types of eating disorders, and we’ll be going over each of them in detail over the next several weeks. This week, we’ll continue exploring one of the more common disorders, emotional eating.

After reading “Are You an Emotional Eater?,” you should be able to identify whether your emotions influence your eating patterns. If you’ve established that they do, this article is for you.

If youre an emotional eater, youll know it!

If you're an emotional eater, you'll know it!

Here, we’ll talk about one of the possible triggers that may be putting you at risk for disordered, emotional eating or binging. Hopefully, by the time you’re done reading, you’ll have a better understanding of one of the reasons why you overeat and how to prevent it from happening in the first place.

Your Own Worst Enemy

There’s no doubt in my mind that just about everyone reading this article has gone on various kinds of restrictive “diets” in the past. Low carbs, low fat, all “clean,” 4 ounces of protein every 2 hours and nothing but veggies at night… I could go on forever.

A million different reasons for dieting exist, and no matter how “healthy” your diet, if it deprives you of comforting foods (ones you consider “favorite”), you will want to indulge at some point.

This is the backbone of emotional eating. If you don’t allow yourself the foods you’ve grown accustomed to consuming, no matter how many times you tell your conscious mind that what you’re doing is best for your body, your subconscious will still feel deprived.

Instincts vs Reasoning

Now think about this for a minute. Deep down, you’re feeling deprived. Your subconscious mind is convinced that you aren’t getting the kind of nutrition that it needs, simply because it isn’t getting the kind of nutrition that your subconscious mind really wants.

Your body can identify the difference between the two, but not your mind — it functions through habit, not logical reasoning.

This means that no matter how hard you try to resist those cookies sitting on the countertop, your subconscious will tell you that you need them. This voice will often be loud enough to overpower your logical mind, telling your subconscious that you don’t really need the cookies… but in the end, your instincts are stronger than your reasoning, which is why you’ll end up not just eating a cookie, but devouring all dozen of them.

Chances are, she'll cave in eventuallly!

Chances are, she'll cave in eventuallly!

Why All Dozen?

Depriving yourself from your favorite foods for prolonged periods of time ends up “convincing” your subconscious mind that those foods don’t come around very often.

So now, your instincts are telling you that your body not only needs those cookies, but also that they’re a rarity. Of course, your thinking mind realizes that this isn’t so, but in the end, your instincts are stronger — which is why you find yourself standing over the countertop, eating as many cookies as physically possible, as fast as you can.

What happens an hour later? What about the next day?

You feel endless guilt about having binged, and either swear to yourself that it’ll never happen again, or just decide that there’s no sense in bothering with trying to lose weight, you’re bound to “fail” again anyway!

Once a few days (or weeks) pass, you’re back on the wagon, making yet another attempt… that never seems to end any other way than what’s described above. Talk about a vicious cycle!

What This Means to You

Take a minute to really let the above sink in. If it rings a bell with you, how do you think you can stop it? Obviously, if you could just stop depriving yourself, that’d be a start, right?

I know what you’re thinking, “But if I never deprive myself of the peanut butter cups I love so much, how am I supposed to lose fat?!” Well, it’s all about moderation.

Even if you’re a competitor getting ready for a show and have plenty of fat to lose, you can still allow yourself small amounts of your favorite foods, or you can prepare your usual meals in ways that are reminiscent of those peanut butter cups (check out our recipe library for for lots of low carb desserts!).

Do whatever you can to prevent yourself from feeling deprived, because once you do, it isn’t a sustainable lifestyle, and you’ll be much more prone to binging.

Stop labeling foods as "forbidden"!

Stop labeling foods as "forbidden"!

There are a few other routes that lead to binging through emotions, and we’ll go over two of them in an upcoming article. For now, I’d love to hear your thoughts regarding the above.

Note: There are many types of eating disorders, and ALL should be treated by a professional. Olicious Life does not make treatment recommendations for any types of eating disorders nor dispense medical advice; only a physician is qualified to determine the proper treatment for any patient. All information within our site and forums is for general education purposes only.






Comments

12 Responses to “Emotional Eating: Instinct vs Reasoning”
  1. Epona says:

    Right on the money! It’s amazing how once your mind says you emotionally need it, logic and reason just goes straight out the door. Willpower has no hold, so you have to make sure you are taking care of yourself so that you have emotional support the correct way. And then we beat ourselves up for not having will power when that’s really not what the issue is.

  2. Jenn says:

    All true…It’s when I’m not “supposed” to eat something that I want it the most…

  3. Nicole says:

    Thanks for the article…it came up, just when I need it the most. Finding moderation is the key, there is nothing ‘wrong’ with having a cookie…but the is a underlying reason that makes some of us eat the whole box, and then some :(

  4. Aly says:

    This article really spoke to me, it’s like it was telling me… ’stop starving yourself you idiot..THAT IS WHY YOU BINGE!’

    I needed thi O, thank you. :)

  5. Bootybootybooty says:

    This comes at the right time! I am making myself a mealplan, and as a perfectionist, I want every little thing to be “right” and “worthy of getting me to my goal”. I realize that I need to relax and indulge every once in a while in order to stay the course AND have a healthy relationship with food!

  6. Kim says:

    I do the same thing here. I won’t eat any of my favorite foods for weeks, and then one day when I know that I have a special occasion it’s like an all or nothing mentality. I’m definitely working on moving past that…. having a few cookies and moving on…. rather than devouring the entire plate of them!

  7. mloveb says:

    Awesome, thank you!

  8. viridian says:

    I’ll be making a few others I know read this, thank you!

  9. Crystol88 says:

    The ONLY way to break the cycle of allowing your subconscious to dictate your life is to become AWARE. Change your thinking strategies from “stinking tragedies” of deprivation and want into the empowering CHOICES.

    I choose to eat this way. Eating this way has consequences. Eating treats and other foods also has consequences. When you’re the one making choices, not your infantile ego (your subconscious), “slip ups” don’t come with all the guilt and self-blame they normally do. You have your “non-diet” food and get on with your life.

    The infantile ego is running amok in our society. Abdicating responsibility for everything from drug use to child abuse to “addictions” has led to the plethora of disorders everyone seems to have (only a few of which are actually legitimate mental illnesses or disorders) and a society full of victims.

    I’m not interested in being a victim. I’m in charge here folks, not the brat deep inside my psyche telling me I “deserve” a bag of chocolate chip cookies.

  10. Christine says:

    I hated when I still ate emotionally. It was the death of me if I ever got sad….I’d eat half the pantry out!!

  11. viridian says:

    Wow, Crystol that was a great way to put that.

    Youre totally right though, everyone in America wants to be able to blame someone else. it’s anyones fault but our own ;)

  12. Bootybootybooty says:

    Crystol! What a great little rant. Thanks for it!

Add Your Comments

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!